Famous Coin Flips: 7 True and Fictional Stories
Famous coin flips are moments, real and fictional, when one toss decided something big. Real examples include the 1845 toss that named Portland, Oregon, and the 1959 flip between Ritchie Valens and Tommy Allsup for a seat on Buddy Holly’s plane. On screen, think Peaky Blinders and Game of Thrones.
Here is the short version of why these famous coin flips stay in our heads. A coin toss turns a hard choice into one clear moment. When the result later turns out to matter, as it did for Portland and for Allsup, the toss becomes a story people retell for decades. Fiction borrows the same idea. Thomas Shelby uses a coin to hand a decision to fate, and a well-known Game of Thrones saying treats a whole family’s fortune as a coin in the air. The sections below cover each story and separate what is documented from what is still debated.
If you landed here after searching “what city’s name was determined with a coin flip” or “who did Ritchie Valens flip a coin with,” you are in the right place. We gathered the most famous coin flips from history, music and TV in one guide. You can also flip a coin online while you read.
Key takeaways
- Famous coin flips range from naming a city to deciding who boarded a plane.
- Portland, Oregon got its name from an 1845 coin flip between Asa Lovejoy and Francis Pettygrove.
- Ritchie Valens won a coin toss with Tommy Allsup for a seat on the 1959 flight. Buddy Holly did not flip a coin; he chartered the plane.
- Thomas Shelby’s coin is a recurring ritual in Peaky Blinders, a way to hand a hard choice to fate.
- The Targaryen saying says the gods flip a coin at every birth, with greatness and madness as the two sides.
- The Wright brothers and a famous racehorse’s ownership were also reportedly decided by a toss.
- Details of some stories differ between sources, so treat them as well-known accounts, not court records.
What City’s Name Was Determined With a Coin Flip? Portland, Oregon

The answer is Portland, Oregon. In 1845, two business partners, Asa Lovejoy from Boston and Francis Pettygrove from Portland, Maine, each wanted to name the new town after their home. They settled it with a coin toss, and Pettygrove won, so the town became Portland instead of Boston. It is one of the most famous coin flips in American history.
The coin was a copper one-cent piece minted in 1835, now called the Portland Penny, and it is kept at the Oregon Historical Society Museum. Most accounts say the toss was best two out of three. The exact house in Oregon City where it happened is still debated, as the Portland Penny page on Wikipedia explains. A few local historians argue the founding of Portland was messier than the coin story suggests, so it is best to treat the tale as well-known lore with a real historical core. If old pennies fascinate you, read our guide to the lucky penny heads or tails belief.
Who Did Ritchie Valens Flip a Coin With? The Day the Music Died
Ritchie Valens flipped a coin with Tommy Allsup, the guitarist in Buddy Holly’s band. It happened on February 3, 1959, during the Winter Dance Party tour. After a show in Clear Lake, Iowa, Holly chartered a small plane to reach the next stop, and there were two spare seats. Waylon Jennings gave his seat to J.P. “The Big Bopper” Richardson, who was ill. Valens, who wanted a break from the cold tour bus, asked Allsup for the other seat, and the two flipped a coin. Valens won.
The plane crashed shortly after takeoff, killing Holly, Valens, Richardson and the pilot, Roger Peterson. Allsup later recalled the toss in interviews, and in an Associated Press report on his death, his son said he saw losing the toss as a blessing. Among the famous coin flips, this is the most somber one. A detailed account of the tour appears in Rolling Stone’s The Last Days of Buddy Holly. As with many old stories, some details differ between tellings, so the broad outline is solid while small points vary.
Who did Buddy Holly flip a coin with?
Nobody. This is a common mix-up. Buddy Holly did not flip a coin. He chartered the plane, and the coin toss was between Valens and Allsup. Jennings’ seat went to Richardson without a toss, because Richardson was sick.
Why Does Thomas Shelby Flip a Coin in Peaky Blinders?
In Peaky Blinders, Thomas “Tommy” Shelby, played by Cillian Murphy, uses a coin as a ritual for hard decisions. Instead of weighing every angle, he lets the toss decide, which fits a character who spends his life in a world of gambling, risk and fate. Reviewers of the 2026 Netflix film The Immortal Man describe the coin as a familiar Shelby ritual that carries across generations of the family.
So why does Thomas Shelby flip a coin? One reasonable reading is that it gives him a way to hand the weight of a choice to something outside himself. The show never treats it as a gimmick. It is more like a superstition and a promise rolled into one. Of all the famous coin flips on TV, his are the most closely tied to a character’s personality. If you want to know why we call the sides what we do, see why is it called heads or tails.
When a Targaryen Is Born, the Gods Flip a Coin
This line comes from the world of A Song of Ice and Fire and Game of Thrones. In the books, Ser Barristan Selmy recalls King Jaehaerys saying that madness and greatness are two sides of the same coin, and that each time a new Targaryen is born, the gods toss it in the air and the world holds its breath. You can read the quote on the A Wiki of Ice and Fire.
In the HBO series, characters repeat a shorter version: every time a Targaryen is born, the gods flip a coin. As Looper notes, it is often used to explain the family’s reputation for madness, and it was reused in House of the Dragon marketing. It may be the most quoted of all the famous coin flips in fiction, because it turns a whole dynasty into a single toss.
More Famous Coin Flips: Wright Brothers, Secretariat and Sports
A few other famous coin flips are worth knowing. According to a short history from Provident Metals, these include:
- The Wright brothers: the pair reportedly used a coin toss to decide who would make the first attempt at powered flight.
- Secretariat: the ownership of the Triple Crown–winning racehorse is said to have been decided by a coin toss.
- Sports: American and Australian football start with a toss to decide who gets the ball, and cricket uses one to decide who bats or bowls first.
These examples show how often people trust a coin when two sides have an equal claim. For the history of the practice itself, our guide on heads or tails meaning and rules is a good place to start.
Why Famous Coin Flips Feel So Dramatic
There is a reason these stories land so strongly. A coin toss strips a decision down to two outcomes, and it happens in a second. There is no room to debate once it lands.
Add the “what if” factor and you get drama. What if Portland had been Boston? What if Allsup had won? What if the Targaryen coin had landed the other way? Famous coin flips work as stories because the alternative is so easy to imagine. They also carry a sense of fairness, since neither side is supposed to have an edge. That is the whole point of using a coin in the first place.
Are Famous Coin Flips Really 50/50?

Mostly, yes. A fair coin gives each side about a 50% chance, which is why people trust it for big and small decisions. Our guide on why a coin toss is 50/50 explains the reasoning, and is heads or tails more likely covers the tiny same-side effect found in research.
One thing worth remembering is that the result of any single toss, even in famous coin flips, tells you nothing about luck or fate. It is just chance. If you enjoy the superstition side of coins, see is heads or tails good luck.
Famous Coin Flips at a Glance
| Story | Year | Who flipped | What was decided |
| Portland Penny | 1845 | Asa Lovejoy and Francis Pettygrove | Whether the town would be named Portland or Boston |
| Day the Music Died | 1959 | Ritchie Valens and Tommy Allsup | A seat on Buddy Holly’s chartered plane |
| Peaky Blinders | Fiction | Thomas Shelby | Hard choices, left to fate |
| Targaryen saying | Fiction | “The gods” | Greatness or madness at birth |
| Wright brothers | 1900s | Wilbur and Orville Wright | Who would try powered flight first (reported) |
| Secretariat | 1970s | Racehorse owners | Ownership of the foal (reported) |
How to Make Your Own Coin Flip Decision
You do not need a famous coin flip to make a good one. Here is a simple way to use a coin for your own choices:
- Write down the two options clearly.
- Assign heads to one and tails to the other before you flip.
- Flip a coin, by hand or with our free online coin flip tool.
- Notice how you feel about the result. If you are disappointed, that may tell you what you really wanted.
If you want a few more tips, see how to call heads or tails.
Final Thoughts
Famous coin flips stick with us because they show how one small moment can change a life, a city or a story. A copper penny named Portland. A backstage toss in 1959 separated Allsup from the plane. A fictional gambler leaning on a coin, and a fictional dynasty that blames the gods’ coin for its fate.
None of these tosses prove that coins have a special power. They show how much we like handing big choices to a fair and simple tool. To keep exploring, browse the coin flip blog, read how a coin flip works, or try our coin flip tool for your next decision.
What are the most famous coin flips?
The best known include the 1845 toss that named Portland, Oregon, the 1959 toss between Ritchie Valens and Tommy Allsup, and the Wright brothers’ reported toss. In fiction, Thomas Shelby’s coin and the Targaryen saying are the most famous.
What city’s name was determined with a coin flip?
Portland, Oregon. In 1845, Francis Pettygrove won a toss against Asa Lovejoy, so the town was named after Portland, Maine, instead of Boston.
Who did Ritchie Valens flip a coin with?
Tommy Allsup, the guitarist in Buddy Holly’s band. They flipped for a seat on the plane on February 3, 1959, and Valens won.
Who did Buddy Holly flip a coin with?
Nobody. Holly chartered the plane. The coin toss was between Valens and Allsup.
Why does Thomas Shelby flip a coin?
In Peaky Blinders, the coin is a ritual that lets Tommy hand a hard decision to fate. It is a recurring part of the Shelby story and reflects how risk and chance shape his world.
What does “every time a Targaryen is born, the gods flip a coin” mean?
It is a saying in Westeros meaning each Targaryen is born either great or mad, as if a coin decided. In the books it traces back to a remark by King Jaehaerys.
Where can I flip a coin online for free?
You can use our free online coin flip for an instant heads or tails result.
Need a Quick Decision?
Flip a coin and let chance decide — instantly, honestly, and for free.
Flip a Coin